I'm having a tad bit of trouble inducting people into Cooperstown, I know there are players who are good, but not "good enough" for the Hall of Fame
My current criteria for Batters is:
200-400+ Home Runs
A decent career batting average (.260-.300+)
1000+ RBI
A 60+ Career WAR
5+ All star selections
2+ Gold Gloves (if applicable)
2+ Silver Sluggers
1+ World Series Ring
Had to be a reasonable star that I noticed through news stories/leading stats (basically I had to know who they were)
Example of a person inducted under this criteria:
For Pitchers:
200+ Wins
sub career 3.20 ERA
sub career 1.20 WHIP
2000 career K's
a 50+ career WAR
a 20 win season
a Cy Young
5+ All Star apperences
1+ World Series Ring
Had to be a reasonable star that I notices through news stories/leading stats
Example of a person who was inducted under this criteria:
Note: Wacha was notably shammed from All Star games due to him never being quite popular for some reason.
I've only had 1 HOF inducee (Wacha) in the last 3 years, I want to know your guy's criteria so I can get a basis of which players should get in and who shouldn't, so what are yours?