OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

Cactusguy21 · 06-22-2018, 04:40 PM

Hi, I have a question about Ootp 19. In the game, are the true player values fixed, or do they change in each individual career I start? Sorry if that didn't make sense, let me give an example.

Take Orioles 2B Jonathan Schoop. He had several middling careers, then a breakout year. Now let's say I had him on my team, and he went back to being a middling hitter for ten years down the road. If I were to play a different Orioles franchise, once again having Schoop, and assuming the impact of injuries is negligible (which is rare, but this is a thought experiment), would there be a chance that Schoop becomes a superstar?

Another example is with prospects. Let's say that LHP Tanner Scott is a bust in one series I do. Would that mean that in every single orioles franchise I play, he's gonna be a bust? Is there a fixed value that says "Tanner Scott is in reality a 2-star player", or could Tanner Scott's true value be 4-star in a different franchise, or 1-star in a third? Obviously we'd never know the true value for certain, but you get what I mean.

06-22-2018, 04:40 PM	#1
Cactusguy21 Major Leagues Join Date: Jun 2018 Posts: 332	True player values, are they fixed? Hi, I have a question about Ootp 19. In the game, are the true player values fixed, or do they change in each individual career I start? Sorry if that didn't make sense, let me give an example. Take Orioles 2B Jonathan Schoop. He had several middling careers, then a breakout year. Now let's say I had him on my team, and he went back to being a middling hitter for ten years down the road. If I were to play a different Orioles franchise, once again having Schoop, and assuming the impact of injuries is negligible (which is rare, but this is a thought experiment), would there be a chance that Schoop becomes a superstar? Another example is with prospects. Let's say that LHP Tanner Scott is a bust in one series I do. Would that mean that in every single orioles franchise I play, he's gonna be a bust? Is there a fixed value that says "Tanner Scott is in reality a 2-star player", or could Tanner Scott's true value be 4-star in a different franchise, or 1-star in a third? Obviously we'd never know the true value for certain, but you get what I mean.