XX Challenge Mode Problems????
 

Is the achievement gunning them down the same thing as catching a player stealing?

If I throw a Maddux but have walked a batter do I not get credit for the Maddux achievement?

I have thrown out 3 or more base runners trying to steal but I guess to get the achievement I need to throw them out on the base paths from the outfield.

I have thrown a few "Maddux" achievements but always had a base on balls and did not get that achievement either.

Thank you for any help in advance.

Gunning them down are OF kills only, not base stealing.

Maddux is <100 pitch CG SO. Nothing to do with walks.

Thank you Matt for responding so fast.
Wish you the best.

No Maddux Again
 

I have thrown a few Maddux and never received credit in the achievements. Here is a post of the latest one. I did get credit for the no-hitter so maybe that has something to do with it.

Is this because maybe I can't get credit for the no-hitter and the Maddux?

I was definitely signed on and completed enough plays and did get credit for the no-hitter.

Thank you for any help.