View Single Post
Old 12-09-2005, 03:17 PM   #107
sebastian0622
Banned
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Posts: 3,465
Quote:
Originally Posted by SWardle
Gee, I wonder how Kerry Collins season has gone this year? I seem to remember some raving lunatic talking about how SUPER Collins would do this year. How he'd have a CAREER year with Randy Moss.

Low and behold, Collins is benched for the rest of the season on a craptastic team. Way to nail another one on the head, buddy!

Steve-O
Collins has a QB rating this season of 79.6, or 6 points higher than his career average and 4 points higher than last season.

That Collins is being benched shows that the expectation is that a QB with Randy Moss will do much better than "just" 5 points higher in QB rating, although 5 points is a lot in QB rating (difference between #6 and #13 QB's this year).

Basically, Collins has played horribly enough to get benched, Moss has been hurt, and Collins STILL has a rating significantly higher than his career average and 3rd highest of his career. I guess I fail to see how this hurts my argument.
sebastian0622 is offline   Reply With Quote