I know I had it set up right, except of course that number 3 middle reliever probably should have been put in the mop up role. I would have understood if the number 2 middle reliever, the 2 setup guys, and the closer had been tired... or even if they had pitched yesterday, or even if they had pitched 2 days ago.
My major problem with my pitching staff is I've gotten unlucky and signed some horrible injury prone middle relievers - 2 of them have been injured for 3+ months of each season (my hoped for number 1 just went down for 13 months in spring trainings after missing 4 months last year). My minor league prospects for relief are stuck in single and double A, nothing good in triple A, and trying to put together a trade for a decent reliever is almost impossible since the AI doesn't give me any ideas about what they might be looking for in prospects... which is a whole different complaint.