Thanks for the input guys. I messed around with the settings some (was up till 3am playing and am paying for it at work today

). I turned off facegen entirely and it seems like now it doesn't automatically create cards at the all-star break.
I'm going to experiment with changing some of the name files from player_# format over to Firstname_Lastname format and see if I can get the cards I want that way.
I can't wait for some 1980's Donruss Card templates to come out

.