[cinemaodyssey]

I am aware that he is on the missing players list. However, he was the starting shortstop on the 1873 New York Mutuals team. Their team picture is listed below, and it stands to reason that he must be in the photo. The team's starters are: Nat Hicks, Joe Start, Candy Nelson, Jim Holdsworth, John Hatfield, Dave Eggler, Count Gedney with Phonney Martin and Dick Higham sharing time in the outfield and Bobby Mathews pitching. Perhaps someone could identify him (maybe through process of elimination) in this picture?