The following two posts are the icons I am using for my awards in my leagues now, they are based upon the real trophies. I'll find the explanation on how to add these into your skins when I find it again... as of right now, I'll just assume you know how to do this if you want these icons.
I'll eventually zip them up as a mod unless someone wants to do it for me. Here they come:
Allstar: (Ozzie Smith's Allstar Ring)
Cy Young:
Gold Glove:
MVP:
Rookie of the Year (Jackie Robinson's Trophy):
World Series MVP, Silver Slugger, Rolaids Relief Man in next post.