If these were in better shape...but they're not. Posted on the off chance they'd be useful. From the top:
Pitcher Larry Corcoran 1880 (three 30-win seasons, a 43-win season, three no-hitters, and two of the first career-ending sore arms - ending his career as an ambidextrous pitcher)
Larry Corcoran
Catcher Tom "Pat" Deasley 1881
Pat Deasley
Second Baseman Joe Gerhardt 1873
Joe Gerhardt
Outfielder Pete Gillespie 1880
Patrick Gillespie