[david limbaugh]

I get the Felix Hernandez answer.

In my 1909 Season Christy Mathewson won the award with a losing record (7-8) while Nap Rucker went 12-3

What made it strange is that Christy pitched for a team that finished 2 games over .500

I understand pitchers wins and losses are not a great measure of success. But they have been using that non-exact 'science' for over a century...