I agree with Matt, though I'd rather see the player from Kentucky get it...
Also, if the Kentucky boy had some sort of other accomplishments going for him like if he set some sort of record (i.e. longest scoreless streak) or if he plays in a hitter's paradise and the other fella plays in a pitcher's park, I could see him being the choice.
P.S. Not sure that I like our team being called the "Horseflies".....