View Single Post
Old 04-09-2016, 08:35 PM   #27493
tnfoto
Global Moderator
 
tnfoto's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Port Angeles, WA
Posts: 12,734
Quote:
Originally Posted by Merkle923 View Post
The absence of the 1951 American League 50th Anniversary emblem that is on the Getty shot of Mantle but not on the supposed home run image got me thinking.

How would that have been possible? It's only a theory, but Mantle went through the 1951 exhibition campaign, right up to the annual pre-season series against the Dodgers, on the Kansas City roster. While newspaper shots of game action from Ebbets Field on April 14 and April 15, 1951 show the A.L. Anniversary emblem, it's possible Mantle's had not been sewn on yet.

That possible clue led me to the box score for the Dodger-Yankee exhibition of April 15, in which Mantle homered in the 8th inning and the next Yankee batter would've been Joe DiMaggio's defensive replacement in center...Number 7, Cliff Mapes.

So the photo is of Mantle's first homer in a major league park, but not his first major league homer. The New York Times box score is below and as an aside, that Yankees-Dodgers series was broadcast on television and radio by the Dodgers. So, one of the announcers who covered Mantle's a) first game in a major league stadium, b) first game in New York, c) first home run in a major league stadium, was a second-year Dodger broadcaster named Vin Scully.
Great detective work! The absence of the sleeve logo had been bugging me as well. Thanks for putting the question to rest.
__________________
TNFOTO: baseball careers ended "Through No Fault Of Their Own"
Facepack updated 4/5/2022 Info & download links here.
Missing player/manager/umpire list or Pegasus UIN list
Download Facepack & more at tnfoto's Baseball Photos Homepage
Photo threads: 2025 Debuts Majors Managers Coaches Umpires Minors Negro League Image Requests General Image Discussion
tnfoto is offline   Reply With Quote