[Cusick]

Tom Vickery won 24 games for the 1890 Phillies, but lost 22. Unfortunately, I don't have a photo of him to use for comparison purposes, but this woodcut from The New York Clipper seems to line up pretty well against the second unidentified player. Again, I couldn't find any other player who made such a close match, and I ruled out Billy Gray on the basis of the same ear not matching in the two photos presented above.