Apparently my team hit around so many times this guy couldn't process it:
The other two five hit players correctly identified who won the game in their respective post-match interviews, and as is visible to the top right, there wasn't a double header where the teams traded 24-7 victories either.
Might be a bug related to three players hitting five or more in the same game? I didn't check Jimmy's Intelligence score in BNN, so if this is a feature please disregard.