Frank Carswell, 1953 Detroit Tigers - he played in 16 games as a 33-year-old rookie, never got a start, and was returned to the minors despite reaching base 7 times in 18 plate appearances (.389 OBP). I don't think we have a decent image of this guy in a Tiger uniform, so here's a highly cleaned (just cleaned, not photoshopped) sample from a recently purchased photo.