Jim Slack, CF
Slack was drafted 11th overall out of Villanova by the San Diego Padres in 1906. By the end of 1907 he was up with the big league club and by 1908 he was the starting CF. He stayed with the Padres for 10 seasons before signing with the White Sox. He made 4 all-star teams, won a gold glove, and was on two of the Padres World Series teams, winning NL Division Series MVP in 1913. He twice led the league in stolen bases and finishes his career 6th in MLB history in steals and 9th in hits.
Career Stats: 8879 PA, 2113 H, 776 SB, .314 wOBA, 104 wRC+, 111.7 ZR, 47.4 WAR, 40.2 JAWS
Koby Webb, RHP
Webb makes into the Hall of Very Good, but falls just shy of Fame. He had a few very good seasons and maintained production for quite some time, starting 340 games for the Padres over 13 years. He made three all-star teams, won a gold glove, and was a three-time World Series champion - twice with the Padres and once with the Indians. He finished 2nd in Pitcher of the Year voting in 1911.
Career Stats: 3405.3 IP, 796 BB, 1308 K, 2.61 FIP, 95 FIP-, 53.0 WAR, 49.0 JAWS
Emmanuel Ahern, LHP
Ahern was a solid, durable starter for many years, splitting time between the Indians, Reds, Orioles, Athletics, and White Sox. He was drafted in the 3rd round out of high school and finished 2nd in Rookie of the Year in 1908.
Career Stats: 3201 IP, 910 BB, 1183 K, 2.74 FIP, 98 FIP-, 44.5 WAR, 46.9 JAWS
Bob Edge, 1B
Edge led the league in home runs twice with 7 in 1906 and 6 in 1908. He was an all-star in 1910, a two-time silver slugger, and won a gold glove. He was taken in the 4th round in 1903 out of Pennsylvania.
Career Stats: 8426 PA, 1973 H, .320 wOBA, 109 wRC+, 87.3 ZR, 31.9 WAR, 29.6 JAWS
Simon Walker, LHP
Walker was drafted in the 13th round by the Dodgers in 1904 out of high school and was quickly traded to the Cardinals, where he spent 9 major league seasons. He was a three-time all-star and was known for his elite control.
Career Stats: 2389.3 IP, 426 BB, 934 K, 2.33 FIP, 85 FIP-, 48.5 WAR, 34.0 JAWS
Eric Olena, RF
Olena's entire career was with the Rangers from 1907 through 1920 after being drafted 1st overall in 1905. He was a two-time silver slugger and one-time all-star. His offensive production was never in doubt, but he was definitely out of place in RF and never had the defensive prowess necessary to be an MVP candidate.
Career Stats: 8500 PA, 1905 H, .339 wOBA, 117 wRC+, -104.9 ZR, 21.4 WAR, 19.9 JAWS
Nelson Avock, SS
Avock was drafted 19th overall out of Kentucky and absolutely should not have played shortstop, but yet that is where the Mets, Braves, and Yankees put him for 11 years. He did win a silver slugger in 1910.
Career Stats: 6734 PA, 1529 H, .303 wOBA, 99 wRC+, -331 ZR, -11.1 WAR, 4.8 JAWS