Tomas Reed, SS
Reed retires as the best position player ever in MLB history, completing his career at age 44. He won 5 MVP awards, Rookie of the year, 7 silver sluggers, and went to 8 all-star games. He was the AL Division Series and Championship MVP but never won a World Series. He was drafted 1st overall out of Oregon State in 1908 and immediately dominated the league, averaging over 8 WAR in five out of his first six seasons. Once he turned 28, his defense fell off a cliff but instead of sticking at shortstop he transitioned into a slugging first baseman. He holds the records for games, at-bats, runs, hits, total bases, singles, RBIs, and career WAR.
Career Stats: 11914 PA, 3100 H, 111 HR, 515 SB, .367 wOBA, 129 wRC+, -28.4 ZR, 76.3 WAR, 64 JAWS
A.J. Aranha, LHP
Aranha never won a Pitcher of the Year award but he did attend 5 all-star games, win a gold glove, and a World Series, taking hom the NL Series MVP the same year. He was drafted 17th overall in 1915 out of Vanderbilt.
Career Stats: 2694.3 IP, 477 BB, 1308 K, 3.06 FIP, 82 FIP-, 60 WAR, 61.8 JAWS
Vladimiro Trejo, RF
Trejo was a scouting discovery out of the Dominican Republic in 1908 and debuted in 1912 with the Marlins. He won an MVP in 1914, went to four all-star games, won a gold glove and was a 7-time silver slugger.
Career Stats: 6721 PA, 1796 H, 679 SB, .374 wOBA, 139 wRC+, 30.9 ZR, 49.8 WAR, 43.6 JAWS
D.J. Leverton, CF
Leverton was a premier power hitter while playing a good CF. He won three gold gloves, one silver slugger, and went to four all-star games. Originally drafted 1st overall out of Weatherford, TX, Leverton was an elite prospect who debuted at age 21 and played his entire career with the Blue Jays.
Career Stats: 8467 PA, 2103 H, 109 HR, 582 SB, .331 wOBA, 105 wRC+, 149.1 ZR, 44.6 WAR, 41.7 JAWS
Owen Clodfelter, 1B
Clodfelter retires as the home run king at 143. However, he wasn't capable of much else. Even with all the pop, his offense was just barely above average and his defense was atrocious at 1B. Oddly enough, he played one game at CF in 1924.
Career Stats: 11058 PA, 2776 H, 143 HR, .342 wOBA, 109 wRC+, -170.7 ZR, 13.3 WAR, 13.4 JAWS