Verne Rodriquez, LHP
Rodriquez was also a borderline candidate, but the fact that he is a lefty and a Pitcher of the Year winner pushed him over the edge. His JAWS value is solidly in HOF territory, but his career WAR total is quite low. He won a gold glove and went to four all-star games along with being a part of two World Series teams.
Career Stats: 2923.7 IP, 854 BB, 912 K, 3.67 FIP, 94 FIP-, 47.6 WAR, 62.7 JAWS
Blake Martin, 3B
Had Martin played a little better defense, he might find himself in the Hall as well. He made two all-star teams and won one silver slugger and one World Series. He is one of nine 3B in history to accumulate more than 2000 hits and one of five to have more than 100 HR.
Career Stats: 8490 PA, 2001 H, 112 HR, .348 wOBA, 110 wRC+, -60.1 ZR, 32.7 WAR, 30.1 JAWS