Quote:
Originally Posted by Charlatan
McReynolds is a "go-to" good defensive outfielder, so he actually gets used on a lot of teams. I'm sure you realize this but you could always platoon him against RHP and use him as a defensive sub.
|
Ive seen him everywhere and can't understand it. I've tried him on 4 of my 6 teams (none of which ever made it above gold) and he's downright terrible. Awful, horrendous. He has never hit higher than .179 for me. Never had a +WAR. He is okay defensively (his ratings suggest he should be amazing, but he doesn't play that way). I even held firm waiting for him to turn it around and even after 3 seasons he never broke .179 or positive WAR.
That's my experience. I vote "no" on Mcreynolds.