Quote:
Originally Posted by justpatrick
I know I may sound like a broken record on this, but I really feel like the game does not value historical players´defense properly. George Sisler for example was universally recognized by contemporaries as one of the finest fielding firstbasemen in the game and yet he´s a 53, which I find quite unrealistic. And in what universe is Tris Speaker a 44 in CF? I realize it was towards the end of his career but that cannot possibly be accurate. There´s tons of more examples, these are just the tip of an Everest of an iceberg.
|
The thing is that historical players were a lot less athletic that mostly nowadays players, therefore you can't rate them as high as contemporary players...
Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk