Mario Herrera, 3B
Herrera has a strange Hall of Fame case. He only went to one all-star game, but yet his overall value ranks up there with Aidan Rice and Jody Davison. He wasn't a "compiler" either, having a mostly normal career length, taking over the starting job at age 20 and moving into a backup role at age 34. He was just so consistent with 2-5 WAR every year. He also had great baserunning value, leading the league in stolen bases in both 1985 and 1986. He ranks second all-time in third basemen for stolen bases, just behind Alonso Carvajal who played in the days of huge stolen base numbers of the early 1900s.
Initial Acquisition: Signed in 1977 with the Yankees out of Venezuela
MLB Awards: Tomas Reed MVP Awards - 0, Timo Fernandez Rookie of the Year Award - 0, Youssef Raadouni Gold Glove Awards - 0, Paul Vines Slugging Awards - 1, All-Star Appearances - 1, World Series Championships - 0, Playoff MVPs - 0
Career Stats: 11346 PA, 2850 H, 89 HR, 610 SB, 0.33 wOBA, 108 wRC+, -14.4 ZR, 53.7 WAR, 44.8 JAWS
Will Fonseca, 3B
Fonseca actually had more awards at third base than Herrera, but most of those came over the span of just a couple of years. The early parts of his career were only about average value, keeping him just out of the Hall.
Initial Acquisition: Number 8 overall pick by the Athletics out of Limestone
MLB Awards: Tomas Reed MVP Awards - 0, Timo Fernandez Rookie of the Year Award - 0, Youssef Raadouni Gold Glove Awards - 0, Paul Vines Slugging Awards - 2, All-Star Appearances - 2, World Series Championships - 1, Playoff MVPs - 2
Career Stats: 9359 PA, 2251 H, 256 HR, 7 SB, 0.337 wOBA, 112 wRC+, -24.4 ZR, 42.6 WAR, 35.8 JAWS
Holden Hare, CF
Initial Acquisition: Number 12 overall pick by the Expos out of El Capitan
MLB Awards: Tomas Reed MVP Awards - 0, Timo Fernandez Rookie of the Year Award - 0, Youssef Raadouni Gold Glove Awards - 0, Paul Vines Slugging Awards - 2, All-Star Appearances - 2, World Series Championships - 0, Playoff MVPs - 0
Career Stats: 9652 PA, 2156 H, 271 HR, 256 SB, 0.315 wOBA, 102 wRC+, -10.7 ZR, 38.3 WAR, 33.9 JAWS
Zach Reynolds, LF
Initial Acquisition: Number 74 overall pick by the Cubs out of North Buncombe
MLB Awards: Tomas Reed MVP Awards - 0, Timo Fernandez Rookie of the Year Award - 0, Youssef Raadouni Gold Glove Awards - 0, Paul Vines Slugging Awards - 0, All-Star Appearances - 2, World Series Championships - 2, Playoff MVPs - 0
Career Stats: 7134 PA, 1913 H, 114 HR, 419 SB, 0.334 wOBA, 114 wRC+, 4.2 ZR, 37.9 WAR, 33.7 JAWS
Al Ireland, 1B
Initial Acquisition: Number 41 overall pick by the Orioles out of Houston
MLB Awards: Tomas Reed MVP Awards - 0, Timo Fernandez Rookie of the Year Award - 0, Youssef Raadouni Gold Glove Awards - 4, Paul Vines Slugging Awards - 0, All-Star Appearances - 3, World Series Championships - 2, Playoff MVPs - 3
Career Stats: 6873 PA, 1966 H, 62 HR, 234 SB, 0.337 wOBA, 113 wRC+, 95.9 ZR, 35.2 WAR, 31.8 JAWS
Cyrus Jolly, RHP
Initial Acquisition: Number 64 overall pick by the Angels out of Pepperdine
MLB Awards: Tomas Reed MVP Awards - 0, J.P. Avila Awards - 1, Timo Fernandez Rookie of the Year Award - 0, Youssef Raadouni Gold Glove Awards - 1, All-Star Appearances - 3, World Series Championships - 0, Playoff MVPs - 1
Career Stats: 2347.2 IP, 659 BB, 1272 K, 3.99 FIP, 97 FIP-, 34.5 WAR, 37.4 JAWS
Jeremiah Rowe, RH Reliever
Initial Acquisition: Number 22 overall pick by the Marlins out of Plant
MLB Awards: Tim Beckman Relief Awards - 1, All-Star Appearances - 1, World Series Championships - 2, Playoff MVPs - 0
Career Stats: 849.2 IP, 142 SV, 479 BB, 739 K, 4.03 FIP, 99 FIP-, 17.9 WPA, 4.8 WAR, 17.5 JAWS
Brecon Rogers, RH Reliever
Initial Acquisition: Number 42 overall pick by the Cubs out of The Woodlands
MLB Awards: Tim Beckman Relief Awards - 0, All-Star Appearances - 2, World Series Championships - 2, Playoff MVPs - 0
Career Stats: 965.2 IP, 198 SV, 354 BB, 669 K, 3.58 FIP, 87 FIP-, 3.6 WPA, 12.5 WAR, 15.3 JAWS
Josh Marjanian, RH Reliever
Initial Acquisition: Number 225 overall pick by the Brewers out of Pendleton
MLB Awards: Tim Beckman Relief Awards - 0, All-Star Appearances - 1, World Series Championships - 0, Playoff MVPs - 0
Career Stats: 801.2 IP, 169 SV, 304 BB, 560 K, 3.67 FIP, 89 FIP-, 4.2 WPA, 8 WAR, 5.4 JAWS