[fuzzy_patters]

I would do it. I play a lot in the dead-ball era, and that plays a factor. Guys with average stuff are rare during that time period, which helps explain why the pitcher has been an effective pitcher. Defensively, errors are plentiful in that era, and that second baseman looks like he will make many of them considering the high error rates and low strikeout rates of that era. Lastly, the second baseman has a good combination of contact and power, but power is worthless in that era. I think he’s overrated considering your environment. I always look to trade guys with average error ratings and good power when playing in the dead ball era because the AI will overvalue them.