two images from the
Explore Chicago Collections
"TITLE Baseball player, Beck, Whales, following through after throwing a baseball on the field at Weeghman Park.
DATES 1914."
"TITLE Baseball player, Fred Beck, Chicago Whales, posing in catching stance by a racetrack fence.
DATES 1914."
they look like two different people to me, the first image resembles your second pic to my eye, as does the attached tobacco card scan-