Quote:
Originally Posted by Charlie Hough
I'm not looking to do a 3-year recalc, but I tried all the other aspects of those settings, and they did not fix the problem. For example, I used those settings but with 1-year recalc, and Crucito Carvajal, a guy who played in class A in 1979, ended up on the Pirates' MLB roster as one of its top relievers. He had some excellent stats in A-ball, but those should not translate into a two-star pitcher at the MLB level, with better movement than all but one pitcher in the entire Pirates organization.
I am seeing many similar instances where players who were multiple levels below the MLB in the same season are on the MLB roster and have clearly not been adjusted or weakened properly.
In other cases, the AI is making bizarre roster decisions such as placing a guy who had a 6.00+ ERA and 1.7+ WHIP as the #1 starter for the Detroit Tigers, ahead of four other starters who all have better ratings.
There seem to be some really strange things going on with the historical settings and AI these days, so it's not looking good at the moment. If anything, 1-year recalc and the ratings settings for minor league stats should already take care of this, but it seems like something with the real minors is not working correctly. It seems like OOTP is not properly adjusting or weakening minors players and isn't properly applying the minor league modifiers in all instances.
|
Gotcha.
Can't disagree with you on this. Too many people saying similar things. I have steered clear of historical minors for different reasons, so don't have my own experiences to go by. Would be interested in doing so at some point, but certainly not until the apparent issues have at least been addressed and hopefully resolved.