Best Nine Of 1875
Catcher - Deacon White - Washington Nationals
White became the best catcher by default after Cal McVey changed his position this offseason. Still White has been among the most consistent batters in the league with a .336 career average with 217 RBI. White it also a great leader and mentor to the entire roster.
First Base - Levi Meyerle - Hartfold Dark Blues
Meyerle had a dominant year leading the American League with a .378 average and .813 OPS. Meyerle is at the prime of his skill and 25 years old and was well deserving of his MVP award.
Second Base - Ross Barnes - Washington Nationals
Yes Barnes did have a down season but still ended with a .284 average and lead the league with 15 steals. The 3 time MVP is sure to put the disappointing season behind him and remains by reputation the most popular player in the league.
Third Base - Jim O'Rourke - New Haven Elm Citys
Likely the best mustache in the league and a handsome figure, O'Rourke is one of the most feared hitters in the league. A 125 OPS+ including 40 doubles in his three seasons this line drive hitter is making his home town of Bridgeport proud.
Short Stop - Jim Holdsworth - Hartford Dark Blues
Long Jim hit .358 last season with an .867 OPS but hasnt been able to play everyday for a variety of reasons. When right, Holdsworth is a great talent with a wonderful arm and reach at a key position. Many expect him to break through in 1875.
Left Field - Lip Pike - Philadelphia Whites
One of the best players of his generation, Pike seems to be as good as ever. driving in 41 runs with a .328 average all while managing his team Pike has 323 total hits in his baseball career. He is smart, quick to the ball, and a very serious competitor as he tries to get the Whites to a pennant.
Center Field - Dave Eggler - New York Mutuals
A huge star as the Mutuals bring home the championship and Eggler is the model of a winner. He lead the league with 300 at bats and never missed an inning of action with a .310 average and 11 triples he is a spark that few teams can deal with. He will be expected to do even more this season as Cal McVey takes the mound and the Mutuals look to repeat.
Right Field - Paul Hines - Chicago White Stockings
Just having turned 20 years old, Hines has already gained much respect across the league. He can play multiple positions and puts his body on the line in every game. Hines continues to hit with a .317 average and 186 runs scored in his three very strong seasons.
Pitcher - Albert Spalding - Boston Red Stockings
There are many great arms in the game but when he is at his best, still no one is better then Spalding. He helped Boston bring home its first pennant with an 18-9 record and a 4.2 WAR. Spalding is also a great hitter and spends some time playing center field.