I have noticed the exact same problem and submitted a bug report previously. We definitely need to make sure this isn't in OOTP 24. While the instances are relatively rare, the game is definitely converting A-level stats as MLB-equivalent in some cases, or it's not properly adjusting the ratings for minor league level once they're calculated.
I've seen some cases where a player comes in as a 5-star MLB superstar-level performer when he should be in A ball, and that's not reasonable at all.
I've also seen cases where players who had really strong AAA stats are given ratings that are a bit too high for what they did in MLB. But I don't mind those as much. Those are at least believable "what if" cases.
|