Yeah, it's a stumper. Here's my advice.
Before you do anything, backup your save.
One setting not shown that I'd like you to check first of all is Pitcher Stamina in STATS & AI. That should be NORMAL.
I have tried to replicate the error, without luck. Are you using v23?
Here's KCR on same date for me in v23.9.102
And here's Vida Blue, all as you'd expect.
I am, as they say, perplexed.
So these are just Hail Mary sorts of things to try because, like I said, I'm stumped.
- Switch the Pitcher Stamina HISTORICAL recalc setting to CAREER
- Use REAL STATS instead of NEUTRALIZED (Garlon will hate me for that one...)
- Enable Development (G won't like that either...)
- Run full re-scouting.
Keep us in the loop please, we'll try get this sorted for you.
G