I have "by position" selected for the overall rating. I wonder if it would be lower if I had it set for all players.
Anyway, the game takes long time players out of action at young ages with career ending injuries. Because of that I'm OK with someone like Hite making MLB.
I don't know what would happen with six MLB at bats. However consider George Korinc from a past game with 17 real life MLB IP.
George Korinc