I found this random picture on ebay of someone claiming to have found this rare picture of Jim Creighton and they put a side by side comparison. There are some facial details that look similar but im not entirely convinced which is why i am posting this here since every sabr person who specializes in this stuff ignored me for months on it. However, the 2 known photos of Creighton show him looking off to the side a bit so his full face isnt visible in either but in this one, the man in gthe photo is looking straight forward. I was told by a friend that she thought it was Levi Meyerle at first glance but I honestly have no idea. It could just also be some random non-baseball dude who happened to have a photo taken for all we know.
https://ibb.co/hDHwsPY
https://ibb.co/yyvhGZy
https://ibb.co/wyKC1Hs