Quote:
Originally Posted by RUKen
I had thought Robinson was taller than he was (he is listed at 5'11"), so I agree now with Kellogg, and your placement of Robinson. I also agree with Leifield, Keen, Haley, Kelly, Noel, Averett, and Irving.
You've stated that you agree with my placement of Camnitz, but you've also placed Keliher there (second from left in the top row). I think it's a pretty good match for Camnitz. I still like Keliher fourth from the left.
The man third from the left in the bottom row appears to be wearing a Pirates jersey under his sweater, as well as a Pirates cap, so I do think he is a ballplayer. He is identified as Wally Rehg in your earlier post. That would leave only the third from the right in the bottom unidentified. It could be Ona Dodd; I wish there were a better image of him.
Camnitz / ? / Keliher / ?
|
I mispoke when I said in the bottom row third from left, I meant third from right.
Thanks for pointing out that I was confused in nominating 2 players for the same placement. I agree with Camnitz second from left top row. Suggest Keliher as the bottom row extreme right. By a process of elimination that would leave Irving as the player third from right in the bottom row.
Attached is the exemplar I have been using for Ona Dodd