View Single Post
Old 07-31-2024, 06:38 AM   #29
Garlon
Hall Of Famer
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 4,351
This is from an 1871-2023 game I made yesterday. Negro Leaguers "Real" (MLE) stats they were given for their carer vs their career results in OOTP.


Player "Real" vs OOTP result

Batters

BA/OBP/SLG


Cool Papa Bell .294/.361/.405 vs .294/.361/.399

Willard Brown .313/.364/.487 vs .318/.369/.491

Oscar Charleston .313/.372/.494 vs .305/.362/.469

Ray Dandridge .303/.334/.394 vs .308/.340/.396

Bud Fowler .285/.336/.393 vs .294/.337/.409

Josh Gibson .306/.375/.536 vs .313/.381/.536

Frank Grant .299/.361/.436 vs .299/.361/.431

Pete Hill .289/.350/.383 vs .287/.352/.374

Judy Johnson .286/.325/.399 vs .305/.345/.419

Buck Leonard .300/.380/.484 vs .310/.394/.510

Pop Lloyd .302/.342/.393 vs .296/.335/.385

Biz Mackey .310/.360/.450 vs .304/.354/.441

Louis Santop .305/.357/.431 vs .307/.362/.429

Turkey Stearnes .314/.371/.514 vs .309/.364/.501

Mule Suttles .297/.360/.500 vs .307/.369/.512

Ben Taylor .300/.348/.404 vs .302/.353/.404

Cristobal Torriente .313/.378/.449 vs .320/.385/.454

Wilie Wells .285/.362/.423 vs .279/.355/.407

Sol White .280/.313/.389 vs .291/.326/.399

Jud Wilson .342/.397/.510 vs .346/.403/.512


In this group of batters, the average OPS result in OOTP was .003 greater than their real stats in the file.



Player "Real" vs OOTP result

Pitchers

ERA/WHIP/ERA+ vs ERA/WHIP/ERA+


Ray Brown 3.49/1.31/117 vs 3.48/1.31/118 (292 wins)

Andy Cooper 3.96/1.35/107 vs 3.78/1.30/112 (243 wins)

Leon Day 3.91/1.39/104 vs 3.86/1.41/104 (187 wins)

Martin Dihigo 4.02/1.38/105 vs 4.12/1.40/103 (256 wins)

Bill Foster 3.66/1.34/116 vs 3.58/1.30/121 (189 wins)

Jose Mendez 2.72/1.16/118 vs 3.24/1.22/103 (261 wins)

(For Mendez he was able to pitch far more innings in OOTP, which brings his averages down, but he did manage to win 261 games.)


Satchel Paige 3.17/1.22/131 vs 3.47/1.28/119 (390 wins)

(Paige ended with 1000 more innings than his real stats, but that is not unexpected considering he plays for 27 seasons. He ended up with 390 wins)


Bullet Rogan 3.49/1.32/110 vs 3.41/1.26/121 (244 wins)

Hilton Smith 3.65/1.33/113 vs 3.67/1.33/111 (218 wins)

Joe Williams 2.84/1.19/119 vs 3.02/1.19/115 (389 wins)


The average pitcher in this group had an ERA in OOTP that was .08 greater than their real stats in the file.

Last edited by Garlon; 07-31-2024 at 07:06 AM.
Garlon is offline   Reply With Quote