LOL. I saw this and thought this was the same guy my game keeps wanting to turn him into a dominant pitcher as well. It's a clear error: he was a mediocre 3B who had a couple relief stints in blowouts. But that's JEFF Hamilton. Joey was legit enough. I figure if someone threw a 2-hitter IRL, he has an outside shot at a no-no.
I don't know why the engine sees something like
1989 Jeff Hamilton and wants him to be a 5 star reliever.