Quote:
Originally Posted by UKBaseballfan
Nice enhancement.
There has been considerable debate in respect of the identifications of the players in the 1880 Troy team photo.
Confirmed identifications for images of Bill Tobin are attached which question the location of Tobin as top left in the team photo. These are attached.
Alternate identifications for the player top left are Ed Cogswell and Tim Keefe.
|
My understanding is that the photo is the 1881 Troy team due to the presence of Hankinson. I also remember reading Mark Fimoff had ruled out Keefe being pictured. For my professional opinion, I believe that Cogswell is the player on the far left.