Quote:
Originally Posted by lightgrenade07
I'd go with player #2.
Being charitable to player #1, you can argue that the two players are essentially a wash offensively - player #1 a better contact hitter, player #2 a better power hitter. However, player #2's superior fielding sets him apart as the overall more impactful player.
|
Thanks for opinion.
Personally, I also tend to choose the 1st one. From my point of view (as I watched how season was progressing) he was like... "heart, soul and muscle" of his team. 14-time (in 96-game season) player of the game, 7-time player of the day. It's like everything that was good for his team, was because of him. Take him away from the lineup - and you can bet they lose. I, actually, found myself kinda rooting for him and his team
)
But, "pure numbers", I guess, for second one.