THE HOT CORNER
Baseball coverage from the inside — Sacramento Prayers and the FBL
By Claude Playball | Baseball Insider & Analyst | Host, "Hot Corner" Podcast
______________________________
June 1 – June 13, 1993 | Games 55–67 of the Sacramento Prayers 1993 Season
______________________________
FIVE GAMES UP ON JUNE 8TH. ONE AND A HALF GAMES UP ON JUNE 13TH. SOMEONE WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT?
Five games is a comfortable division lead entering a road trip against your primary rival. One and a half games is a number that makes you check the standings every morning before coffee. Sacramento did not lose a catastrophic amount of ground over these thirteen games — the Prayers went 6-7, which is an ordinary below-.500 stretch that any team will produce at some point in a 162-game schedule — but the timing and concentration of that damage is the part that deserves honest examination. Four of those seven losses came in the final five games of this stretch, three of them at Spirits Grounds, where Fort Worth won the series three games to one and pulled to within a game and a half of first place. The Spirits are now 40-28, sitting on a three-game winning streak, and holding the AL wild card lead by two full games. They are not a team that is going to lose the division on its own, and Sacramento's head-to-head record against them — four wins, eight losses — is the most uncomfortable number in the entire Prayers database right now.
There are real reasons to maintain perspective. Forty-one wins in sixty-seven games is a .612 winning percentage that projects to ninety-nine wins over a full season. The rotation's aggregate ERA of 3.19 remains the best in the American League. Alejandro Lopez is playing like the most valuable player in this league and nobody in the sport is running bases the way he runs them. All of that is true and all of it remains true even after a 6-7 stretch that exposed the bullpen's depth problems, generated two more confounding starts from the best pitcher in the rotation, and added a significant injury to the arm the front office most needed to stay healthy.
But five games to one and a half in thirteen days is a real number, and this column will not pretend it is not.
______________________________
WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED: A GAME-BY-GAME TOUR
At San Jose: June 1–3
Three games at San Jose Grounds. A 1-2 series loss. Rubalcava gave back six earned runs in 3.2 innings on June 1st — his worst start of the season by a wide margin, game score of 19, the San Jose lineup unloading through four hits including two Campen doubles and a Thomas home run in the fourth that opened the decisive gap. Musco went 3-for-5 with a home run and three RBI and it was not enough because you cannot dig a six-run hole and expect to climb out of it in six innings on the road. Sacramento lost 6-5 and Rubalcava's ERA moved from 2.26 to 2.78 in a single outing.
The June 2nd game was the corrective. Espenoza went 6.2 innings, allowed two earned runs, and gave the Prayers a professional win. Alonzo hit a two-run homer in the third. Rodriguez added a solo shot in the ninth. The 6-2 final was organized and clean, which was the appropriate response to the previous night.
The June 3rd game belonged to Jose Arteaga, who was better than Sacramento on the night — 7.1 innings, one earned run, his cutter functioning as advertised against a lineup that hit it with discomfort all evening. Larson went 7.1 innings himself and deserved a better fate, but Boldrini's two-run homer in the first inning was the kind of early deficit this Sacramento offense struggles to overcome when the opposing starter is dealing. The Prayers left San Jose 1-2 in the series, having been outpitched twice by a rotation with a 5.12 ERA. This happens. It happened here.
vs. Boston: June 4–6
Three games at Cathedral Stadium, two wins, one blowout loss in both directions.
The June 4th game was the cleanest performance of the stretch. Andretti went 6.1 innings and won his eighth game. Law came to Cathedral with a 5-0 record and left having walked seven batters in 3.1 innings and absorbed a loss that looked nothing like his season line. Musco went 4-for-4 with a home run and a walk. Perez hit a two-run shot in the third. Cruz hit a three-run homer in the fourth. The 8-1 final put Salazar — recalled from Triple-A at the end of May — through 2.2 clean innings of his Cathedral return. Everything worked.
The June 5th game worked for Boston, and I will simply account for it plainly. St. Clair allowed six earned runs in 2.2 innings in the third inning as Boston sent ten men to the plate and produced seven runs against him and the inherited-runner gauntlet that followed. Yoon was excellent for the Messiahs — 6.1 scoreless innings, steady command, nothing Sacramento could solve. The final score was 8-0. The box score note that Ryan was injured while pitching during the game matters more to the next three weeks than the final score does.
The June 6th game was Rubalcava restoring the appropriate order of things. Eight innings. Five hits. Three earned runs. Nine strikeouts. A win that moved him to 6-5. Rodriguez went 3-for-4 and drove in two. Prieto closed it for his eighteenth save, ERA now 4.50 — a marginal improvement from the 4.85 he was carrying into this stretch. The 5-3 series win was the correct result against a team playing below .500.
vs. Charlotte: June 7–9
Three games against the Monks at Cathedral. Two wins, one loss, and a June 9th footnote that redirected the rest of this stretch in ways the scoreboard did not immediately reveal.
The June 7th game needed ten innings and produced the loudest moment Cathedral Stadium generated all week. Lopez led off the tenth against Gaias and hit his fifteenth home run over the fence, and the Monday night crowd that had been sitting through nine innings of anxious, evenly matched baseball finally exhaled. Espenoza had been dealing with Jason McCord all night — two two-run home runs, both with two outs, both off Espenoza — and the fact that Sacramento clawed back twice before Lopez ended it is a testament to the kind of roster this organization has assembled. Dodge threw two scoreless innings in extra innings and won his fourth game without a loss.
The June 8th game was Larson at his best — 7.2 innings, five hits, zero runs, eight strikeouts, game score of 77 — and the 4-0 win put Sacramento at 40-22 with a five-game division lead. Gutierrez finished the eighth with two more strikeouts. It was, through June 8th, the cleanest and most dominant version of what this rotation can produce. The footnote was Francisco Hernandez colliding at a base late in the game. That collision produced a fractured foot and a minimum three-week absence, which did not announce itself immediately but arrived in the injury report the next morning with full clarity.
The June 9th game had a different character entirely. Andretti allowed five earned runs in seven innings — Dennison hit one out in the second, Gonzalez hit a two-run shot in the sixth, and Cowley was simply better on the night, holding Sacramento to two runs over 6.2 innings of work that the Charlotte lineup made look easy by comparison. Caliari entered and faced one batter, Dodge entered with inherited runners and got one out before the injury that ended his night and sent him to the IL, Salazar came in and held the rest. The 5-2 loss moved Sacramento to 40-23. The loss of Dodge — ERA 1.71, four wins, four saves, the most dependable arm in the bullpen — is the event of June 9th that will matter most over the following three weeks.
At Fort Worth: June 10–13
Four games at Spirits Grounds. One win. The series that squeezed the division lead from four and a half games to one and a half. I will account for each game and then return to the larger meaning.
The June 10th game is the game of this stretch that I find most difficult to write about, because it represents a version of injustice that baseball produces with casual indifference and that no reasonable accounting system can adequately address. St. Clair threw 7.2 innings. He allowed one earned run. He threw ninety-nine pitches with excellent control — zero walks, five strikeouts — and the single run he allowed came on an Izzy Rodriguez two-out RBI single in the fifth after a Schultz leadoff double. Sacramento went 0-for-11 with runners in scoring position. Eleven hits on eleven at-bats with men on base who could have scored and did not. The Prayers left thirteen runners on base. Varela went 6.2 innings and allowed nothing. The final was 1-0 Fort Worth. St. Clair's record went to 4-3. He deserved a win and did not receive one, and the universe offered no explanation.
The June 11th game was an offensive eruption on both sides with Rubalcava departing early at the center of it. He allowed five earned runs in 3.1 innings — eight hits, including an Reza double in the fourth that broke open a 5-0 Sacramento lead — and left with the inherited runners that would eventually determine the shape of the game. Scott came in for three scoreless innings and earned his first win. Musco hit a two-run homer in the first. Baldelomar hit a two-run shot in the seventh. The Prayers won 10-7, Prieto getting his nineteenth save in the ninth, and the win felt both legitimate and slightly fortunate given what Rubalcava's line looked like. This is now two starts in eleven days in which the best pitcher on this roster gave back multiple runs before the game was three and a half innings old. That is no longer an outlier. That is a pattern, and this column intends to address it directly below.
The June 12th game was Espenoza's third consecutive start in which he allowed runs in the first inning and spent the rest of the afternoon playing catch-up. An Izzy Rodriguez double and a Reza double in the first inning produced two Fort Worth runs before Espenoza had recorded three outs. He allowed five earned runs in four innings total. Bautista — recalled from Triple-A the previous day specifically to replace Dodge's lost innings — threw three scoreless innings, the best news of the game. Cruz had two errors. The 6-3 loss put Sacramento at 41-25.
The June 13th game belonged to Marty Blythe, who went 6.2 innings and allowed two earned runs while Fort Worth's lineup did things to Larson that the June 8th Charlotte lineup could not. Caballaro tripled in the first. Reza tripled in the third. Gomez delivered a two-run single in the sixth with the bases loaded to put the game away at 5-2. Larson went 5.1 innings, allowed five earned runs, issued four walks and committed a balk, finishing with a game score of 32 — the inverse of everything he produced against Charlotte five days earlier. Caliari threw 2.1 innings out of the bullpen and was serviceable, which is more than he has been on several recent outings. The 6-2 final completed Fort Worth's series win and shrank the division lead to one and a half games.
______________________________
THREADS WORTH PULLING
Alejandro Lopez — Fifteen home runs. Twenty-five stolen bases. A .403 on-base percentage. A WAR of 3.0 that leads this team by a full win over the next closest position player. The walk-off homer on June 7th was the dramatic peak of this stretch, but the more representative Lopez performance is the June 12th game at Fort Worth, where he took three walks against a pitcher who had no interest in letting him beat the Spirits, reached base three times, and still found a way to steal two bases. He is making the opposing manager make decisions before the first pitch is thrown, and the residual benefit to the hitters behind him in the lineup is real and measurable. Twenty-five stolen bases in sixty-seven games projects to sixty on the season. No one in this league is doing what Lopez is doing.
Edwin Musco — Ten home runs, thirty-six RBI, a .250 average that undersells his June production. In this stretch alone Musco went 4-for-4 with a homer against Boston on June 4th, hit his ninth and tenth home runs, and drove in multiple runs on three separate occasions. The shortstop who entered 1993 as a respected veteran contributor has produced a quietly excellent offensive season — his 1.7 WAR trails only Lopez and Cruz among position players — and the defensive continuity he provides at shortstop has been consistent enough that the late-game substitution patterns that move him around the infield look seamless rather than disruptive.
Danny St. Clair — He went 7.2 innings, allowed one run, threw ninety-nine pitches efficiently against the team with the second-best record in the American League West, and lost 1-0. His ERA is 3.32. He has now had two excellent starts, two rough starts, and one transcendently unlucky start in his last six outings. What I want to say about St. Clair is that the version he showed on June 10th is the version this rotation needs him to be — under control, getting ground balls, keeping the offense in the game — and that the 1-0 loss he absorbed is the kind of result that tests a pitcher's confidence in ways a 4-0 loss does not, because a 4-0 loss can be blamed and a 1-0 loss can only be absorbed. How he responds in his next start will be informative.
Eli Murguia — Returned from the IL on June 10th after the high ankle sprain that kept him out since mid-May, and has appeared in four games since, going 4-for-12 with a home run and a handful of starts in left field and at DH. The .299 average and .390 OBP in limited time this season suggest a hitter who was not at full capacity before the injury and who may be building back toward something more useful. With Hernandez out three weeks, Murguia's health matters in a direct and practical way. The offense needs at least two of its three left field/DH options functioning simultaneously, and right now Hernandez is not available to be one of them.
______________________________
THINGS THAT KEEP ME UP AT NIGHT
Rubalcava's two bad starts are now a pattern, not an anomaly — This column said after the June 1st San Jose start that one poor outing from a 2.26 ERA pitcher was an outlier, not a trend. I was defending a position the evidence supported at the time. The June 11th start against Fort Worth — 3.1 innings, five earned runs, eight hits, game score of 25 — is the second poor start in eleven days against two different opponents, and it changes the conversation. His ERA is now 3.19. His season WAR leads the pitching staff at 3.6. His underlying stuff is not deteriorating — the strikeout rate is intact, the walk rate remains low. What is happening in these starts is that he is not surviving the innings in which hard contact concentrates. In June 1st it was the fourth inning. In June 11th it was the fourth inning again. Something is happening in the fourth inning of Rubalcava's starts that is not happening in any other inning, and the pitching coach and the organization need to understand what it is. This is not a crisis. It is a question that requires an answer before July.
Sacramento's head-to-head record against Fort Worth is four wins and eight losses — I want that number to sit in this column's pages without immediate contextualization, because the contextualization can wait. Fort Worth has beaten Sacramento eight times in twelve meetings. That is a .333 winning percentage for the division leader against the team it must separate from to win the division. They are not twelve games apart in the standings; they are one and a half games apart because Fort Worth keeps winning the games that the two clubs play against each other. The remaining head-to-head schedule matters enormously, and if the Prayers cannot find a way to win the series the next time these teams meet, the division race will be genuinely tight in September.
The bullpen without Dodge — Dodge went on the IL on June 9th with an injury sustained while pitching. He was 4-0 with a 1.71 ERA. He was the most dependable arm in the Sacramento relief corps. His absence reshapes the bullpen arithmetic in ways the current available options cannot fully resolve. Gutierrez remains excellent at 1.35 ERA, but the gap between Gutierrez and the next tier — Bautista recalled to fill innings, Salazar back from Triple-A, Wright and Caliari both carrying ERAs above four — is significant. Prieto continues to close games and continued to allow home runs at a rate that exceeds what any organization would design for its ninth-inning option. The bullpen without Dodge is a different bullpen than the one that helped produce the first forty wins of this season, and the gap is not small.
The rotation's soft underbelly — At their best: Rubalcava dominant, Andretti reliable, Espenoza efficient. At their worst: Rubalcava exiting in the fourth inning, Espenoza allowing runs before the second out of the first, Larson issuing four walks and committing a balk in 5.1 innings against a lineup he shut out five days earlier. The distance between the best and worst versions of this rotation is not a pitching staff with depth — it is a pitching staff with three excellent starters who occasionally don't show up on some night, and when two of them don't show up in a four-game series against Fort Worth, the result is 1-3 in the series and a division lead that shrinks by three and a half games. The question heading into the second half of June is whether the rotation can get all five starters to perform above replacement level on the same week. June 10-13 was the clearest evidence yet that this is not guaranteed.
______________________________
INTEL FROM AROUND THE FBL
Fort Worth at 40-28 is the lead story of this podcast and I have already discussed them at length in the concern section above. What I will add here is that the Spirits are playing the best baseball of any team in the AL West right now — six wins in their last ten, a three-game winning streak entering the week of June 15th, and a roster that has stayed relatively healthy while Sacramento has cycled through injured list transactions at a rate that the front office did not budget for in April. They are a legitimate threat to win this division and anyone telling you otherwise is not watching the standings carefully.
San Jose at 37-29 is the number that snuck up on me while I was focused on Fort Worth. The Demons are 8-2 in their last ten games, sitting three and a half back in the division and leading a crowded wild card conversation at the top of the AL wild card standings. Sacramento went 3-4 against them this season, which puts the Prayers below .500 in head-to-head play against the division's third-place club. The upcoming schedule includes no more San Jose games in the immediate term, which is both a relief and a missed opportunity, because the way to address a 3-4 record against a division rival is to play them again, not to wait.
Brooklyn remains the class of the AL East at 40-26. Their recent stumble — 5-5 in the last ten — opens the door slightly for Baltimore, who is 36-30 and on an eight-game winning streak. If Baltimore's current run continues into late June, the AL East race will be tighter than the standings suggested a month ago, which changes the wild card mathematics for every team involved.
Phoenix at 43-25 continues to be the most impressive team in either league. The Crucifixes have the best record in the FBL by two games and a pitching staff that has yet to show any meaningful vulnerability. Sacramento's record against them is 1-2 from the earlier interleague series, which is the honest accounting of where these two organizations currently stand relative to each other.
______________________________
FROM THE INBOX — The Hot Corner Mailbag.
Siobhan Callahan from Midtown writes: "Claude — the division lead was five games eight days ago. Now it's one and a half. I'm trying not to panic but I'm struggling. Give me something to hold onto."
Here is what I will give you. The Prayers are 41-26. That is still the best record in the American League West and the second best in the American League. The rotation's collective ERA is still the best in the league. Alejandro Lopez is still doing things that no other player in this league is doing. The lead shrank because Sacramento went 1-3 against Fort Worth in Fort Worth, not because the team collapsed — and teams that win the division do not require a wire-to-wire lead to earn the pennant. They require more wins than the team below them when September ends. Sacramento has a roster capable of producing those wins. Hold onto that. The panic is premature. The attentiveness it suggests is not.
From "Head-to-Head Harold" Asante of Land Park, who informs me he has calculated the Prayers' head-to-head record against every opponent in the FBL going back to 1987 and maintains the spreadsheet voluntarily, without anyone asking him to: "The head-to-head record against Fort Worth is 4-8. How serious is that?"
Serious enough that I put it in the concern section without immediately softening it, which I hope communicated the weight I assign it. Four wins and eight losses against your division rival is a problem that compounds over time — every series loss is a swing of multiple games in the standings rather than a simple one-game deficit. The good news is that there are games remaining between these clubs and those games are the mechanism by which the head-to-head record corrects itself. The bad news is that Fort Worth has demonstrated, eight times now, that they know how to beat this version of the Prayers. Whatever adjustments are available — lineup construction, pitching matchups, bullpen deployment — need to be identified and implemented before the next series. Harold, I suspect you already knew all of this when you sent the email, but I appreciate the platform.
From "Benefit-of-the-Doubt" Fumiko Nakagawa of East Sacramento, who writes that she has given Rubalcava the benefit of the doubt so many times this season she is starting to feel like his publicist: "I want to give Rubalcava the benefit of the doubt but two bad starts worries me more than one. What's your honest read after June 11th?"
Your instinct is correct and your concern is proportionate, which I suspect is more than Rubalcava's publicist would tell you. My honest read is that the situation is worth genuine monitoring without warranting the alarm some observers will assign it. His ERA went from 2.26 to 3.19 across two starts, which sounds dramatic until you remember that the underlying ERA was unusually low for a pitcher working through an inning that concentrated hard contact. The strikeout rate is intact. The walk rate is intact. The stuff, by every account I have, is intact. What is happening in these fourth innings looks more like a specific vulnerability that opposing offenses have identified than a mechanical collapse. Watch his next two starts carefully. I will be — and unlike his publicist, I will report what I actually see.
From "Bullpen Bedros" Parseghian of Rancho Cordova, a self-described "relief pitcher enthusiast" who admits this is not a common hobby but stands by it: "What is the front office going to do about the bullpen? Dodge is out, Ryan is out, and the options behind Gutierrez and Prieto are not inspiring confidence."
Bedros, the relief pitcher enthusiast community is having a rough week and I want to acknowledge that before proceeding. The honest answer is that the front office has two paths: internal solutions, meaning Bautista and Salazar need to be the functional middle-inning options they were recalled to be, or external solutions, meaning the trade deadline in mid-July becomes a bullpen acquisition deadline rather than an optional enhancement window. Bautista's three scoreless innings against Fort Worth on June 12th were the most encouraging bullpen development of this stretch and suggest he may be at least part of the answer. Whether the deadline becomes a necessity or a luxury will be determined by what we see over the next three weeks. Stay tuned. You more than anyone.
______________________________
Claude Playball has covered Sacramento Prayers baseball for eleven years. The Hot Corner publishes throughout the season. Questions and correspondence are welcome.