THE HOT CORNER
Baseball coverage from the inside — Sacramento Prayers and the FBL
By Claude Playball | Baseball Insider & Analyst | Host, "Hot Corner" Podcast
______________________________
September 17 – October 3, 1993 | Games 147–162 of the Sacramento Prayers 1993 Season
______________________________
CHAMPAGNE, OCTOBER, AND THE WORK THAT REMAINS
They poured the champagne somewhere during the Houston series, in a Cathedral Stadium clubhouse that had been waiting for the moment since the equipment trucks arrived from spring training in February. Six consecutive championships from 1987 through 1992. Twenty-four playoff appearances in franchise history. Thirteen championships total. The players embraced each other and yelled and sang and drank, and Jordan Rubalcava told reporters it feels amazing every single time regardless of the margin, and everyone in that room understood that the margin this time — sixteen games over Fort Worth, a .648 winning percentage, one hundred and five wins — was the most comfortable they had enjoyed in a long time. The celebration was earned and the celebration was deserved.
Then the celebration ended, as it must, and the relevant question became not what Sacramento accomplished in the regular season but what it intends to do in the next three weeks. Fort Worth is waiting in the Division Series. Baltimore is waiting in the League Championship Series, if both clubs advance as their records suggest they will. October has its own rules, its own mathematics, its own cruelties and generosities that the regular season does not prepare you for regardless of how many times you have been there before. One hundred and five wins gets you into the building. It does not win the championship. I have watched this franchise long enough to know the difference, and the Hot Corner intends to document every step of what comes next.
But first, a final accounting of the regular season, and a proper look at the individuals who built it.
______________________________
THE FINAL MILES: GAME BY GAME
At Baltimore: September 17–19 (1-2)
The series that most of Sacramento had anticipated as a playoff preview delivered exactly what it advertised: three competitive, high-scoring games against the best team in the American League East, with Sacramento winning the series two games to one while managing one of the most alarming bullpen sequences of the entire season.
September 17th was Espenoza going 7.1 innings and allowing four earned runs against a Baltimore lineup that produces offense at every position in the batting order — and then Prieto coming on to inherit two runners in the eighth, allowing a Pamplin two-run double that tied the game, and then walking two batters in the ninth while Mele singled through the right side to win it. Lopez hit two home runs. It was not enough. The familiar September pattern of good starting pitching and a ninth-inning implosion produced a 5-4 loss in a game Sacramento had led for seven and a third innings.
September 18th was Rubalcava having the worst start of his season — four and a third innings, six earned runs, three home runs including a Frauenheim three-run shot in the fifth — and the Sacramento offense and bullpen combining to win anyway. Cruz returned to the lineup and hit a two-run home run in the second. Musco hit his thirtieth. Murguia hit his ninth. Alonzo hit his fourteenth. Bautista won it in relief. Gutierrez held runners. Dodge closed. The 9-8 win was the kind of baseball that makes September interesting and managers anxious simultaneously. In the middle of it all: Prieto was injured while pitching, the nature of the injury not immediately disclosed.
September 19th was Larson going five and a third innings against Felix Medina — the same Medina who had entered the game at 5-0 — while Salazar threw two and two-thirds innings of critical middle relief and Dodge closed it with sixteen pitches. Torres hit a two-run pinch home run in the sixth — his first of the season — and Rodriguez delivered a two-run double that proved decisive. The 6-5 win took the series. Also noted in the box score: Cruz was injured again while throwing the ball. His season, and his October availability, became the question that defined the flight home from Baltimore.
vs. Houston: September 21–23 (3-0)
The division clinched during this series, and the precise moment matters less than the fact of it. Houston arrived at Cathedral Stadium at 73-77 and departed having lost three straight games, including one in which Andretti threw 6.1 innings and allowed no runs on ninety-two pitches with zero walks — the Andretti who has been the most consistent pitcher on this staff since April, the one who arrives at his starts organized and leaves them having done exactly what he intended. The September 21st shutout performance, combined with a Bautista and Salazar finishing the final innings cleanly, was a statement about what this rotation is capable of when it is functioning at its ceiling.
The September 22nd game produced thirteen Sacramento runs and a Perez three-run home run in the third, while Espenoza won his fifteenth game with seven and a third innings and the Houston bullpen surrendered nine runs in the eighth inning alone — Baldelomar tripling with the bases loaded being the blow that ended any remaining competitive tension.
The September 23rd game was Rubalcava. Five and a third innings, six hits, zero runs, seventy-eight pitches. Lopez hit his thirty-ninth home run in the seventh. Rodriguez delivered a two-run single in the second that gave Sacramento the lead it never relinquished. Caliari threw one and two-thirds clean innings. Gutierrez threw one inning. Dodge saved it with sixteen pitches. And in the game notes at the bottom of the box score: Rubalcava was injured while pitching. He had thrown seventy-eight pitches. His season stood at 19-8 with a 2.73 ERA and what may be the finest individual pitching performance this city has witnessed in a decade. The nature of the injury, and whether he would be available for October, became the only question worth asking.
vs. El Paso: September 24–26 (2-0)
Larson won his thirteenth game on September 24th — seven and a third innings, zero earned runs on four hits, ninety-four pitches — against a El Paso club that has finished thirty-four games behind Sacramento in the division. Lopez hit his fortieth home run. Musco went three for four with two RBI. The win was clean and efficient.
The September 25th game required a committee effort after St. Clair was injured while pitching in the second inning with biceps tendinitis, delivering one and two-thirds innings before departing. Bautista threw three and a third clean innings. Salazar threw three more. Dodge saved it. Rodriguez hit the only run of the game, a solo home run in the third, and it held for nine innings against a pitcher named Josh Bradford who was, genuinely, excellent — seven innings, six hits, one run, a game that El Paso would have won most nights. Sacramento won 1-0.
September 26th was Andretti's finest start of the season and an argument for the ages: nine innings, one hit, zero runs, one walk, four strikeouts, 102 pitches, a complete game one-hitter that produced a game score of 88 and a final of 13-0 that would have been more if Andretti had needed more. Lopez, F. Hernandez, Cruz, and Torres all hit home runs. It was Andretti's nineteenth win and the kind of start that belongs in the conversation whenever his 1993 season is discussed. The El Paso series was two wins in two games and the rotation had demonstrated, in consecutive starts, that Larson and Andretti were fully operational heading into October.
vs. San Jose: September 27–30 (3-1)
The final home series of the regular season opened with a loss — Espenoza four innings, five earned runs, a Sacramento lineup that managed four hits with runners on base — and the kind of afternoon that reminds a team what San Jose's lineup can do in its best moments. Francisco Hernandez was injured while throwing the ball during the game and did not return, adding one more name to an injury list that had grown uncomfortably long.
The September 28th game brought the most welcome news of the final week: Rubalcava started. Six innings, three earned runs, 109 pitches, a win that Gutierrez finished and Prieto saved. He was not dominant — he allowed a three-run Adams home run in the fourth — but he was present and functioning, and the sight of him taking the mound five days after the September 23rd injury was the most significant development of the final homestand. Mollohan delivered a two-run double in the seventh that proved decisive, and the word "Mollohan" appearing in a clutch at-bat sentence deserves at least a moment of acknowledgment as a testament to what September roster depth looks like.
The September 29th game was Larson — six and a third innings, two earned runs, eight strikeouts against a San Jose lineup that has been competitive in this series all season — while Gutierrez won and Ryan saved and Lopez hit his forty-third home run. The 3-2 final was exactly the kind of tightly managed win that a team with one eye on October plays when it does not need to do more.
The September 30th walk-off was the final game at Cathedral Stadium in 1993, and it was resolved in the manner this season has most frequently been resolved: Musco with three hits and five RBI, Perez with a home run and the walk-off RBI single in the ninth, the Cathedral crowd on its feet for the last time until October. Salazar started and allowed six runs in six and two-thirds innings — the consequences of an emergency deployment for a relief pitcher who was not built for that role — and Ryan threw two and a third clean innings to win his fifth game. Lopez hit his forty-fourth home run. Perez hit his twentieth. The final home record: 60-21. The season-long dominance at Cathedral Stadium was the most reliable fact about this team's 1993 performance.
At Tucson: October 1–3 (1-2)
Sacramento won the October 1st game behind Andretti's twentieth win — his twentieth win, a number that belongs in the opening sentence of his offseason résumé — six and two-thirds innings, zero earned runs, while Perez hit two home runs and Rodriguez hit his twentieth and Bautista finished cleanly. The final was 7-2 and Andretti's season ERA settled at 2.90, a number that does not adequately describe what he contributed to the 1993 Sacramento Prayers but comes closer than most.
October 2nd was Espenoza winning his sixteenth, seven and a third innings against a Tucson lineup that scored one run off a Chavez home run in the first and nothing after. Lopez hit his forty-fifth. Perez hit his twenty-third. Prieto saved it with a clean ninth. The record was 105-56.
October 3rd was Rubalcava in his final regular season start — seven innings, two earned runs, 109 pitches, fifteen ground outs — and a ninth inning in which Prieto allowed two runs, received the loss, and Gutierrez entered with the bases loaded and allowed the walk-off single that gave Tucson a 4-3 win. In the third inning of that game, Jesus Hernandez was injured while running the bases. The diagnosis delivered later: a torn posterior cruciate ligament, ten months, out for the duration of the postseason. He will not be in Cathedral Stadium in October. His season is over. The final record: 105-57.
______________________________
THE ONES TO KEEP YOUR EYES ON
Alejandro Lopez: the complete ledger — Forty-five home runs. Ninety-five RBI. Sixty stolen bases. A .940 OPS. A WAR of 8.0 that leads every position player in the American League and ranks among the highest single-season marks this franchise has produced in the post-expansion era. He won the AL Batter of the Month award for September on the strength of ten home runs and a .280 average in a month where most players are grinding out the final weeks. He entered professional baseball at twenty-one years old. He is twenty-four now. The Hot Corner has been saying since May that he is the best player in the American League. The final box score agrees.
Bernardo Andretti: twenty wins — Twenty wins and seven losses. A 2.90 ERA. A 5.4 WAR. A career that began in 1979 and has arrived in September 1993 at its most productive single-season point. He threw a complete game one-hitter against El Paso on September 26th, a six-and-two-thirds-inning shutout against Houston with zero walks, and a complete game win on October 1st that delivered his twentieth. He is thirty-three years old. He is in the final year of his contract. He has been the most reliable starting pitcher on a staff that leads the American League in ERA, and the question of what he does next offseason — whether Sacramento retains him, and at what price — is the most significant roster decision the organization will face in November. The Hot Corner's position is that you do not let twenty-win, sub-three ERA starters walk.
Edwin Musco: the quiet thirty-one — Thirty-one home runs. One hundred and twenty-one RBI. A .298 average and a .882 OPS from a thirty-three-year-old shortstop. His WAR of 6.9 trails Lopez's 8.0 on the team but leads the rest of the roster by a meaningful margin. He hit the walk-off Musco double in the ninth inning on September 30th that was, in some ways, the punctuation mark on his regular season — not the home run but the double, the RBI double, because that is what Musco has been all year: the player who delivers the run that Sacramento needed, in the inning when Sacramento needed it most. He won the AL MVP in 1989. He is playing better baseball now than he was then, in a quieter way, on a roster where the attention has concentrated elsewhere. The franchise should acknowledge what he is giving them before October reminds everyone at once.
Steve Dodge: the closer Sacramento needed — Eighteen saves. A 1.83 ERA. A WHIP of 0.91. A batting average against of .185. In the final sixteen games of the regular season: nine saves, a 1.15 ERA. When the Hot Corner began arguing in June that Dodge should be closing games, the ERA was 1.37 and the argument was statistical. Six months later the ERA is 1.83 and the argument has been validated by the postseason deployment: Dodge is the ninth-inning option, Prieto has been moved to lower-leverage situations, and the bullpen has not blown a late-inning lead in three weeks. The transition happened through a combination of necessity and, one hopes, intention, and the results speak in a language that does not require translation.
______________________________
THE HONEST QUESTIONS
Rubalcava's injury status is the only question that matters for October — He was injured September 23rd. He started September 28th and October 3rd. His pitch counts in those starts were 109 and 109. His ERA over those two starts was 3.00, which is not his season ERA of 2.77 but is not alarming. What is worth noting is that he allowed nine hits in thirteen innings across those two appearances — more contact than the first twenty-six starts of his season generated — and that the quality of his stuff, based on the output, was not quite what it had been. Whether that reflects a healthy pitcher who had a difficult two weeks or a pitcher managing an injury that has not fully healed is a question that Sacramento's medical staff will answer before the Division Series begins. The answer determines whether this team has the best pitcher in the American League available for October or whether it is managing without him. There is no middle ground on that question.
The injury list entering October is longer than any championship contender would prefer — Jesus Hernandez is out for ten months with a torn PCL. St. Clair is on the IL with biceps tendinitis, eligible to return after the Division Series — which means he is unavailable for the Fort Worth series. Cruz has been injured twice since September 4th and his throwing-arm issue from September 19th requires clarification before anyone can confidently project his October role. Francisco Hernandez was injured September 27th while throwing. The roster that enters the Division Series will look different from the one that won one hundred and five games, and the construction of the October roster — who is available, who is protected, who contributes — is the most important front-office task of the next four days.
Prieto's postseason role requires a clear decision before the first pitch — He finished the regular season at 33 saves, nine losses, and a 5.02 ERA. The losses are the more honest number: nine losses for a closer means nine games where Sacramento was in a position to win and did not, and the causal relationship between those losses and Prieto's late-inning performances is documented in this column across eight months of writing. Dodge closes. Gutierrez is the setup arm. Prieto pitches in situations where a run allowed does not end a game — which is a real and useful role that he can fill effectively, as the September 22nd hold against Houston demonstrated. But the era of unconditional ninth-inning deployment is over, and the postseason cannot afford to rediscover that lesson in the middle of a series against Fort Worth.
Fernando Salazar wrote a contract extension letter to Jimmy Aces — Two months after Gil Caliari wrote his second letter requesting a return, another second letter arrived from the Sacramento bullpen, this time from a veteran ace pitcher. Salazar's letter reads: "Mr. Aces, I find it perplexing that I haven't received an offer to extend my contract. I am sure it's an oversight, and I want you to know that I would be willing to entertain offers. Please get in touch so that we can begin discussions as soon as possible." I want to be precise about why this letter deserves a different response than Caliari's. Fernando Salazar is forty-two years old and has a career ERA of 2.54 in 817 appearances and 762 starts — a career ERA, accumulated across a professional life that has produced 185.1 WAR, that belongs in the conversation whenever the best pitchers in FBL history are discussed. His 1993 ERA is 2.83 in 57.1 innings, which is what it looks like when a forty-two-year-old with a shoulder injury tries to contribute through an irregular season. The perplexity in his letter is legitimate. If the Sacramento organization has not communicated with one of the best pitchers in its history about returning next year, that is an oversight worth correcting. The response to that letter should already have been sent.
______________________________
THE LEAGUE AT LARGE
The playoff picture is set. In the American League: Sacramento against Fort Worth, Baltimore against Columbus. In the National League: Philadelphia against Albuquerque, Charlotte against Las Vegas. The bracket is, from a Sacramento perspective, the one that was most probable since August.
Fort Worth finished 89-73 and earned the wild card on the strength of a second half that included the collapse of Columbus's wild card lead in late September. The Spirits' regular season head-to-head record against Sacramento is nine wins and nine losses — perfectly balanced, neither team having established dominance over the other across a full season. They are a lineup built around Benoldi, Reza, and a pitching staff that features John Gillon at sixteen wins and Blythe at sixteen wins, and they lost their closer McLamb in late August. The Fort Worth bullpen that Sacramento faces in October is not the same bullpen that went 3-7 against Sacramento in the first half of the season. It is also not the bullpen Sacramento would have preferred to face. The series will be competitive, the head-to-head record confirms it, and anyone who arrives at Cathedral Stadium for Game One expecting Sacramento to win in three games has not been paying attention to what Fort Worth has done since July.
Baltimore at 101-61 is the obstacle between Sacramento and the World Series. Jorge Jaime won the American League batting title with a .355 average and forty-three home runs and 137 RBI. The Satans won one hundred and one games. They have the best run differential in the American League. They lost David Hernandez — 14-8, 2.49 ERA — to a rotator cuff strain in September, and his absence reshapes their rotation in ways that favor Sacramento at the top of the matchup. The Baltimore series, if it arrives, will test every assumption about what this team is capable of in October. The Hot Corner intends to cover it in full.
On the National League side: Philadelphia won ninety-six games and the NL East, Las Vegas won ninety-one and the NL West, and the franchise most resembling Sacramento's profile — disciplined pitching, contact hitting, a manager with postseason experience — is probably Charlotte at ninety-two wins, now a wild card entry. Phoenix's ten-game losing streak in September transformed what appeared to be a certain NL pennant into a playoff race that Charlotte and Albuquerque eventually claimed. Sacramento's World Series opponent, whoever it turns out to be, will have navigated a competitive National League bracket to get there. None of these matchups will be easy. None of them are supposed to be.
Casey Ford of Columbus — the reliever the Hot Corner flagged in August as the key piece of the Heaven's playoff viability — suffered a sore elbow in late September and is day-to-day for multiple weeks. His absence is significant for Columbus in the Baltimore series. A team that built its second-half run around Ford's bullpen presence now faces a five-or-seven-game series without him against a Baltimore lineup that generates 886 runs per season. The series is more complicated than the records suggest.
______________________________
LISTENER MAIL — The questions you asked and the answers you deserve.
From Rosa Villanueva of the Pocket District, who attended thirty-eight home games this season, who kept a handwritten game log in a composition notebook that now runs to four hundred pages, and who described Andretti's September 26th complete game one-hitter as "the most beautiful nine innings I have watched in twenty years of attending baseball games": "Should Bernardo Andretti be the Cy Young Award winner?"
Rosa, the four-hundred-page notebook is the most committed act of fandom I have heard about this season and your opinion on pitching deserves to be taken seriously on those grounds alone. The Cy Young case for Andretti rests on twenty wins, a 2.90 ERA, and 5.4 WAR across 229.2 innings — a complete, dominant season from a pitcher who arrived at every start prepared and left most of them having accomplished what the team needed. The case against Andretti for Cy Young is Rubalcava: 19-8, 2.77 ERA, 6.7 WAR in 240.2 innings, with a WHIP of 1.04 and a batting average against of .225. Both of these pitchers are on the same team, which means the Cy Young Award will not go to Sacramento twice regardless of what the numbers say. The voter who must choose between them should choose Rubalcava on WAR and innings. The voter who was in Cathedral Stadium for those nine innings on September 26th might choose differently. Your notebook suggests you would know which of those framings is the more honest one.
From Greg Hoffman of Natomas, who coaches high school baseball and who has used the Hot Corner's coverage of the Prieto situation as a classroom exercise in evaluating performance data versus institutional loyalty — a lesson he describes as "relevant to baseball and to most of life": "Given what happened in this period, was the closer transition completed properly or still incomplete?"
Greg, the classroom application is exactly right and the question is the most important one the Hot Corner can address before October. Here is my honest assessment: the transition was completed functionally but not institutionally. Dodge is closing. Prieto is in setup and lower-leverage situations. The results in the final weeks — no late-inning leads surrendered during the nine-game winning streak, the September 30th win requiring Ryan rather than Prieto in the decisive moment — are consistent with a bullpen hierarchy that has reorganized itself around the correct axis. What remains incomplete is the formal acknowledgment that the change is permanent rather than situational, and the October roster construction will tell us whether Aces and the front office have committed to it or whether the first difficult postseason moment produces a regression to the arrangement that cost Sacramento a dozen games this summer. The classroom lesson applies: the data argues clearly for Dodge closing. Whether the institution has absorbed that argument is what we will discover in the first three games of the Division Series.
From Ara Sarkissian of Arden-Arcade, who attended every Sacramento home game in 1993 with his father, who described the September 30th walk-off win against San Jose as "the moment that made the whole season feel real," and who asked his question on behalf of both himself and his father, who he notes "has been waiting for this October since Game 7 in 1989": "What needs to happen for Sacramento to win the World Series?"
Ara, please extend to your father the professional regards of everyone at the Hot Corner, and the acknowledgment that 1989 is a year this program does not forget. What needs to happen for Sacramento to win the World Series is this: Rubalcava needs to be healthy and pitching at his season-long level, which means the injury that removed him from two September starts must be behind him rather than merely managed. Dodge needs to close every critical late-inning situation, which means the organizational commitment to the closer transition must hold under postseason pressure. The lineup needs to produce with runners on base in close games, which is the thing this offense does inconsistently and which October amplifies — the 17-21 record in one-run games and the four-game negative Pythagorean differential are both traceable to the same root: missed opportunities in high-leverage situations. And the organization needs to make clear roster decisions — about Rubalcava's workload, about Prieto's role, about the construction of the bullpen behind Dodge and Gutierrez — before the first pitch at Cathedral Stadium in the Division Series rather than after. Your father has been waiting since 1989. The team he is watching in October 1993 is better than the team that fell short in 1989. Whether it is better enough is the only question left.
______________________________
Fort Worth on Wednesday. Gillon in Game One, Blythe in Game Two, and however many games it takes after that in a series between two teams that went nine and nine against each other across the full season. The Hot Corner will be at Cathedral Stadium for every home game and filing from wherever the road games take us. One hundred and five wins built the foundation. October determines whether it becomes something more. I have been covering this franchise for a long time, and I have never been more certain that what is coming in the next three weeks is worth watching all the way to the end.
Got a question for the mailbag? Find the Hot Corner wherever you get your podcasts.
______________________________
Claude Playball is a baseball insider and analyst and host of the Hot Corner podcast, based in Sacramento, California.