Is there a way to manually select which players make the All-Star team?

[uruguru]

There is an option to all the player to vote, but I'm not sure that's the same thing as selecting each team.

[HerbD]

Originally Posted by uruguru

There is an option to all the player to vote, but I'm not sure that's the same thing as selecting each team.

Yes...I believe you have to be in commish mode and you have to do it before the event date of "All-Star Teams Announced".

When you see "All-Star Voting" in red, in your league dropdown click on it.
It will take you to the "All-Star Voting" page. Next to it there is a tab that says "Manual All-Star Voting". Click on it. The teams will already be filled out by the AI but you can take all of the players off and start from scratch or you can go through the teams and move people off and on at will.

Once you are finished then click on the "Finished" button and the All-Star teams will be finalized.

[uruguru]

Originally Posted by HerbD

Yes...I believe you have to be in commish mode and you have to do it before the event date of "All-Star Teams Announced".

Thank you! I'm pretty tired of seeing those 2-10, 4.30 ERA pitchers make the All-Star games because they have a good FIP or something.

[uruguru]

Originally Posted by HerbD

Once you are finished then click on the "Finished" button and the All-Star teams will be finalized.

btw I had to restart my sim and this worked great!

To give you an example of the swaps I did in the first ASG:

my 5-8, 2.44 pitcher was swapped out for my 7-5, 2.39 pitcher

a 1-3, 6.00 reliever (wtf) was swapped out for a 7-5, 2.65 reliever

and a 7-8, 3.95 starter was swapped out for an 8-6, 3.09 starter

I suspect the culprit for pitcher voting is an overreliance on FIP or somesuch.